In a significant legal development, a Milan court has extended subsidiary protection to a 50-year-old Tunisian woman and her daughters, recognizing the severe risk they face if returned to Tunisia. The decision comes amidst concerns over potential torture and inhumane treatment due to the woman’s alleged involvement in unpaid debts, a charge vehemently denied by her.
The court’s ruling sheds light on the woman’s tumultuous journey, which began with her participation in a political initiative following the Jasmine Revolution in 2011. Despite her lack of culpability, she was embroiled in a legal dispute demanding repayment of funds associated with the initiative. Fearing detention and mistreatment, she sought refuge in Milan in 2018, where she hoped to escape the looming threat of imprisonment.
Judge Pietro Caccialanza, presiding over the case, emphasized the abolition of debt imprisonment in Italy over a century ago, underscoring the nation’s commitment to human rights and dignity. The court expressed grave concerns about the conditions in Tunisian prisons and the potential for police abuse, highlighting the inherent dangers faced by the woman and her daughters if compelled to return to their home country.
Furthermore, the court’s decision reflects broader legal principles and international obligations, recognizing the fundamental right to protection from torture and inhumane treatment. By granting subsidiary protection, the court has affirmed its commitment to upholding these principles and safeguarding the welfare of vulnerable individuals fleeing persecution and injustice.