More than 20 human rights and migrant rights organizations have urged the Italian government, under the leadership of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, to ensure transparency in the way it implements the European Pact for Migration and Asylum. The groups, which advocate for the rights of migrants and refugees, sent an open letter to the government on November 28. The letter expressed concerns about the lack of involvement of civil society organizations in the creation of Italy’s national plan for implementing the pact. These groups called for greater transparency and participation from those who represent migrants and asylum seekers in shaping policies that directly impact their lives.
The letter highlights the critical need for a more inclusive approach. The organizations pointed out that the European Commission had communicated in June 2024 the importance of engaging civil society in the process of implementing the European Migration Pact. However, the groups noted that they had not been included in any discussions about Italy’s national implementation plan. They stressed the urgency of receiving clarification on how they can contribute and provide their expertise to the process.
Among the signatories of the letter are renowned organizations such as Amnesty International, Oxfam Italia, ActionAid, and Refugees Welcome Italia. These groups, along with many others, have called on the Italian government to involve them in the development of the national plan. The organizations have long been active in defending the rights of migrants, and they argue that any policy affecting migrants should be open to scrutiny and input from those directly working with affected communities.
In addition to the human rights groups, the letter was also supported by several members of the opposition, including prominent politicians like Matteo Orfini and Laura Boldrini. These political figures have expressed their concerns about the government’s lack of transparency and have emphasized the importance of ensuring that the voices of civil society are heard in the decision-making process. They argue that it is essential to maintain a democratic and inclusive approach when developing policies that affect vulnerable populations.
The organizations also raised concerns about the discretionary powers granted to individual EU member states under the European Migration Pact. They fear that Italy’s government could use these powers to implement policies that worsen the living conditions of migrants and refugees. Giovanna Cavallo, a representative from the Forum per Cambiare l’Ordine delle Cose, emphasized that the Italian government could exploit its discretion to introduce more restrictive measures that might undermine the rights of migrants.
As part of their demands, the groups have called for a comprehensive review of Italy’s migration policies to ensure that they align with human rights standards. They argue that a more thorough examination is needed to ensure that the rights of migrants are protected, and that any policies introduced under the new pact are fair and humane. The groups are worried that the Italian government could use its position to push through measures that do not reflect the principles of dignity and respect for all people.
The call for greater transparency comes amid rising concerns over the treatment of migrants and refugees in Italy. With the growing number of people seeking asylum in the country, the organizations argue that it is crucial for the government to adopt an open and accountable approach. They believe that involving civil society in the process will help ensure that the migration system remains fair and just for all.
In response to these concerns, MP Giuseppe De Cristofaro has presented an interpellation in the Italian parliament, urging the government to clarify its approach to the European Migration Pact and to engage with civil society groups. The letter from the human rights organizations, along with the actions taken by political leaders, reflects a growing demand for greater transparency and accountability in the implementation of Italy’s migration policies. The hope is that these efforts will ensure that Italy’s approach to migration continues to uphold the rights and dignity of all people.