Council of Europe Secretary General Alain Berset has warned European governments against weakening human rights protections as they introduce tougher immigration policies, insisting that efforts to control migration must remain consistent with international legal obligations.
Speaking to Euronews on November 17, Berset said governments had the right to strengthen immigration controls and deport people who had no legal right to remain in their countries. However, he stressed that such measures must respect fundamental human rights.
He rejected suggestions that Europe was facing a migration crisis or that the right to asylum had become politically unsustainable, arguing that governments could enforce stricter migration rules without abandoning their human rights commitments.
“Human rights are human rights for everybody or for no one,” Berset said.
He explained that European human rights legislation did not prevent countries from deporting migrants whose claims to remain had been rejected. He pointed out that the European Court of Human Rights had upheld some deportations while ruling against others, depending on the circumstances of each case.
Berset also raised concerns about proposals to establish return hubs outside the European Union, warning that such arrangements must comply with European human rights standards.
Return hubs are facilities proposed in countries outside the EU where rejected asylum seekers could be transferred while arrangements are made for their return to their countries of origin.
He said governments considering such arrangements needed to examine their legal implications carefully and hold proper discussions to ensure that human rights protections were maintained.
His comments come as five European Union countries announced a partnership with Rwanda to establish a return hub for rejected asylum seekers.
The initiative has renewed debate over the legality and human rights implications of transferring migrants whose asylum applications have been rejected to countries outside Europe.
Berset expressed regret that preparations for the Rwanda arrangement appeared to have progressed without continued discussions involving the Council of Europe, despite earlier engagement on the issue.
He emphasised that Europe’s migration policies must remain grounded in the rules-based international order, which he described as essential for maintaining stability, peace and predictability.
His remarks highlight the growing challenge facing European governments as they seek to increase deportations, restrict irregular migration and introduce new return arrangements while maintaining their obligations under international human rights law.
